Matt Pitt, left, leaves the courthouse after pleading guilty during a Sept. 26 hearing. (Reporter photo/Mickel Ponthieux)

Archived Story

Pitt pleads guilty to impersonation charge

Published 12:39pm Wednesday, September 26, 2012

By CHRISTINE BOATWRIGHT / Staff Writer

COLUMBIANA – Youth minister Matt Pitt pleaded guilty to attempting to impersonate a peace officer during a hearing Sept. 26.

Pitt, founder of The Basement, originally was charged with impersonating a police officer after Calera Police deputies pulled him over in Calera May 12. Calera Police Chief Sean Lemley said the district attorney’s office and Pitt’s attorney, Pete Johnson, agreed to reduce the felony charge to a misdemeanor charge of attempting to impersonate a peace officer.

Original reports stated Pitt was driving an unmarked Tahoe flashing emergency blue lights down Interstate 65. Deputies asked Pitt if he was a police officer, and he confirmed he was a deputy with the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office. After verifying Pitt was not a law enforcement officer, Calera police arrested Pitt for impersonating an officer.

Pitt posted bond and was released from the Shelby County Jail May 12.

The vehicle was impounded until “a couple of weeks ago” when the district attorney’s office agreed to release the Tahoe without the siren and emergency equipment, Lemley said.

Prior to the sentencing at the Shelby County Courthouse, Pitt apologized for his actions.

“I’m very sorry for any and all trouble I’ve caused the county and the police department of Calera,” Pitt said. “They did conduct themselves in a very professional manner.”

Pitt said the incident has given him a “different passion,” which has enabled him to reach more youth in his ministry.

Judge Dan Reeves warned Pitt not to “fall prey to the same arrogance” that caused him to conduct himself in such a manner.

Reeves sentenced Pitt with two years of unsupervised probation, as well as a $1,000 fine.

Lemley said he was pleased with the outcome.

“The police department has done its job, and I’m proud of how the officers handled the case,” Lemley said. “I’m satisfied with his statement. He didn’t get out of it scott free.”

Editor's Picks

Meet Callie Reed and Shelby

Shelby Humane Society’s pets of the week, Callie Reed and Shelby have it all…except for a forever home. But with your help, they will have ... Read more

Meet Ben and Rally

Need a little bit of happy in your life? We have two featured pets this week that offer oodles of happiness. Rally is an endearing ... Read more

Meet two special girls

Hickup is a friendly grey/white 1-year-old fancy shorthair feline. She likes to lay in your lap and would love nothing more than to curl up ... Read more